On the day before shutdown, I didn’t appreciate how long it would have to be. Maybe I thought that libraries would simply cancel their events and otherwise stay open for those of us who live on books as much as bread and water.
Went home with just two.
On the day of shutdown, which few noticed was the Ides of March, I had already finished one before hearing the reports and seeing the not-at-all-flattened charts that made even the Quack-in-Chief cancel his Duck Dynasty carnivals and stop calling it a hoax.
Two? Should have taken twenty, but a stay of literary execution appeared in my mailbox on the Italian feast day honoring St. Joseph just hours after I finished the second:
Dinner with DiMaggio: Memories of an American Hero.
Intended as a birthday present, it was one day late, but as an Irish-Italian-American, I’ve always observed a three-day holiday, so she who sent it could hardly have missed.
My immediate reaction was delight. Needing a change of pace from my usual here’s-how-to-save-the-world or here’s-why-the-world-cannot-be-saved fare, I crave biographies because they always deliver history. This one offers added consolation to a lifelong fan of the game about to endure a spring without baseball.
But more: A biography of Joe DiMaggio would serve as a sequel to The Big Fella, a richly surprising 2018 bio of Babe Ruth I read a year ago. DiMaggio’s career began about when Ruth’s ended, and ended, purposefully, when Mickey Mantle, pointedly, replaced him.
And yet more: The gift is from a full-blood first generation Italian-American I’ve known since college, fully aware that I’m a half-blood who would crave a memoir about an Italian, by an Italian, and, if that’s not enough, with a foreword by Francis Ford Coppola.
Written by Dr. Rock Positano, the doctor who, in 1990, finally relieved DiMaggio of the bone-spur pain that ended his career in 1951, Dinner describes their close friendship. In effect, the doctor became DiMaggio’s New York guardian and fixer for the decade up to his death in 1999.
You have to to endure a lot of hero-worship and outright hagiography—in the opening chapters the word icon appears on every other page—but it’s a fascinating look a life for Italians from the 30s into the 60s. What I experienced was minuscule, the very end, muffled for me by my Irish name. This book lets me know it was still going strong.
Positano is eight years younger than I, 39 younger than DiMaggio. He grew up a brawler in Brooklyn and told stories that mirrored those of DiMaggio in San Francisco four decades earlier. While Positano offers many reasons for the odd-couple friendship—from curing the foot to keeping intruders at a distance to arranging for restaurant rendezvous with those the Yankee Clipper wanted to meet—he is either too modest or innocent to claim what his narratives make most clear: DiMaggio saw him as a younger version of himself.
DiMaggio impressed Positano as a man who taught without trying to teach, as when he chided a star-struck furniture mover at the doctor’s office for being late by quoting Martin Luther King’s 30-year-old exhortation always to do the best job you could not matter what it was—complete with King’s choice example of sweeping streets.
Most of Dinner’s stories are told at restaurants all over NYC, all of them Italian, with names from every place and background: Isaac Stern, Henry Kissinger, Michael Bolton, Elle MacPherson, Woody Allen, Tom Hanks, and on and on with occasional reminiscences of Charlie Chaplin, Lauren Bacall, Marlene Dietrich, Humphrey Bogart.
Not to mention Joltin’ Joe’s thoughts on Mohammed Ali, Lou Gehrig, Fidel Castro, Joe Lewis, Ted Williams, George W. Bush, Pete Rose. Or his crossing paths with Ruth Bader Ginsburg, James Earl Jones, Sonia Sotomayor. Or, most delicious of all, his regard for the tributes paid him in Ernest Hemingway’s The Old Man and the Sea and Simon & Garfunkel’s “Mrs. Robinson.”
Most revealing are topics DiMaggio refused to discuss publicly, which created his aloof reputation before he left the game: Marilyn Monroe, his wife of nine months; Frank Sinatra, a close friend turned “pimp”; the Kennedys, “low class shanty bastards.” In time, Positano heard them, and in part Positano shares them with this in mind:
“(DiMaggio) was painfully aware of his place not just as an icon, but also as part of history. He had spent much of his life playing to a future generation of journalists, historians, and fans… I wrote this memoir… to define Joe’s place in history and in the setting of the town that made him legendary… He was a complex man, both a demon and a hero… So many have portrayed him as one or the other, which oversimplifies the man he was…”
All of which makes Dinner with DiMaggio a feast, with sumptuous dishes—history, baseball, arts & entertainment, politics, and foot and ankle medicine thanks to advances Positano made in the field thanks to his unwell-heeled patient—all so very Italian.
All of which makes me want to serve it in my mother’s family name.
-30-







