When I saw the question, I scrolled down to the comments thinking I would surely find the answer.
Is it spelled gray or grey?
I’ve long thought the two were interchangeable, like flutist and flautist, but without the change in pronunciation. I was never sure, and even now my spellcheck has underlined grey and flautist in red. And there it is again!
The answer came quickly. They are both correct, but Americans commonly write gray while Canadians, Brits, Down Underers, and others prefer grey. Simple and harmless enough, and I’m grateful to know the reason even though it won’t increase my income, make me lose weight, regain my lost youth, sharpen my chess game, facilitate my musicianship, improve my German, teach me Italian, gain me Irish citizenship, or enable me to make lasagna or spinach pies.
But the mud hit within the first five comments: “Well, we have a Supreme Court justice who can’t define the word woman.”
Next: “And six others who think one man is above the law.”
Like tennis, it then went back and forth several times, completely divorced from life’s persistent question of gray vs. grey. One wag tried to break the spell by noting that the thread was now “blue vs. gray.” Buy that guy a beer! On me! Too bad, though, that historical humor was lost on the trollers, and the volley continued.
Eventually, one earnest fellow said what many were likely thinking:
Why must a simple, honest inquiry, the answer to which I’m sure many are not sure of, turn into political back & forth garbage with each side trying to antagonize & humiliate the other? Take your childish arguments elsewhere!
Since I create enough on-line controversies of my own and often confront friends when I think they go awry, I had already resolved to stay out of this. But this fellow was singing my song, not just on-line but in public. So I jumped in:
Good question, and I share the sentiment of wanting to keep things in context. That said, it has appeared to me that it is always started by one side. That, then, puts the other side in the position of responding or letting it slide. And many on that other side believe that if you don’t respond, it sticks.
If I may interrupt myself: That has always been the first reason political junkies give for Democrat John Kerry’s loss to George W. Bush in the 2004 presidential election. He did not respond to the “Swiftboat” attack ads. And it is now among the top reasons offered for Kamala Harris’ loss in November regarding relentless ads aired during sports broadcasts painting her as obsessed with sex-change operations for lifers in penitentiaries. She never countered that the policy was in place during Trump’s administration.
Now, as I was saying:
Someone then looks or listens in, and it appears that both sides deserve equal blame. Maybe both sides deserve some blame for carrying on or for the way they carry on, but if you look at who instigates this childishness (your word), I think you’ll find one side far more culpable than the other.
While writing this, I wasn’t thinking of social media, but of a Renaissance Faire where I’ve performed as a strolling flautist (or flutist) since 1499. At the end of each day I’m standing, playing, and bantering with people as they leave. Lot of jokes to leave ’em leaving laughing.
Most successful by far was, “Farewell, and thank you so much for spending your money– Oooops! Ah, ah, ah, I mean your day, your day with us! Your day, I meant to say!” Laughter loud and unanimous from all within hearing–until an uptight higher up at the faire heard it, thought it a criticism, and had it banned it from my repertoire.
That was about eight years ago, after which my best line has been “Come back next year! We’re going to put Galileo on trial!” Not as uproarious as the money joke, but it allowed me to go on, like a boxer throwing one-twos instead of a single haymaker.
Holding up my pipe: “Did you know Galileo’s father was a flutist? Or a flautist? A flautist or a flutist?”
Laughter always pauses as smiles await the punchline and someone asks: “What’s the difference?”
“Flutist or flautist? Flau or flu? Achoooo! One is a telescope with holes,” I offer while holding one end of mine to one eye and pointing the other at the sky. “That’s what gave G Junior the idea when he was a little kid grasping for daddy’s tools of trade,” pointing it directly at the face of anyone nearby.
To those in a hurry, a simple but loud final jab: “Bring some fruit, we’ve got the verdict!”
To those with whining kids: “Ya, I’d be screaming, too, if someone dragged me out of the Renaissance and took me back into the 21st Century.” Sometimes the kid stopped crying and looked back in wonder as I played a few notes.
Say all of this loud enough at the end of a day, and it’s as if laughter rides the waves of the crowd as it exits.
After the year we were shuttered due to the plague, we re-opened in 1521. In these past four seasons, I’ve heard something that didn’t exist previously. Not many, but enough to be noticed would call back: “Put Biden on trial!” and “Try Kah-Mah-Lah,” and a few more in that vein.
Not once was the name Trump or that of any other Republican imposed.
We need to make this distinction. And we need to point it out when others don’t make it. This is not at all to say that the Democrats are perfect. Far from it, and their fear of offending each other keeps them far from it. As does the straitjacket they force upon humor and spontaneity. Worst of all, their pathetic attempts at moderation in the face of outright crimes such as Israel’s war on Gaza keeps them farther from it yet.
Yet they are open to dialogue, which the other side is not. The other side has done all it can for over 40 years to gut Social Security while Democrats have protected it. Ditto the environment. Ditto civil rights. Any failure to make this distinction reinforces the superficial view that “they are all the same” which leads many to wallow in cynicism and dismiss “them” or “Congress” as “all the same.” The resulting damage makes me wonder if it is done out of carelessness or if it is deliberate–calculated along with so much else to undermine Americans’ faith in anything regarding self-governance.
Arguably the most American drama ever written, Death of a Salesman insists that “Attention must be paid.” To do that, distinctions must be made.
Including my own. Am I a gray flutist or a grey flautist? The color may be interchangeable, but the noun depends on how much I get paid.
-629-
























