“Is our convenience worth the destruction?” asks one of the three young women in Remember, winner of the “Best Young Filmmaker Award” at this year’s Earth Port Film Festival screened at the Firehouse Sunday.
Struck me as a question to be asked–and pressed–on any and all candidates running for any office as we now realize the consequences of not just ignoring climate change, but of continuing our reliance on fossil fuels and plastics that worsen it. All for the sake of convenience.
The women in the film are too young to recall it, as are most if not all of the good folks at PortMedia which, along with Transition Newburyport, staged the event, but the question is a searing echo of Robert Kennedy in the presidential campaign of 1968:
Our answer is the world’s hope. It is to rely on youth; not a time of life but a state of mind, a temper of the will, a quality of the imagination, a predominance of courage over timidity, of the appetite for adventure over the love of ease.
After a three-year hiatus due to Covid, the otherwise annual Festival, born in 2012, resumed with founder Elizabeth Marcus and PortMedia’s Sarah Hayden as co-hosts for eleven films ranging from three to 18 minutes, as well as from soberingly serious to whimsically entertaining–while still making environmental points.
Winners of the festival’s other two awards cover that range. A Fistful of Rubbish, “Best Short Film,” is a documentary styled as a western in which the bad guy is rusted metal, slimey slop, crunched plastic, stained fabric, worn-out tires, and all kinds of other junk tossed into a desert with characters modeled on Clint Eastwood, John Wayne, and an uncanny Henry Fonda look-alike. But the most fascinating character is the chaplain at the “brown” town’s church. While Fistful drew more than a fistful of laughs for its satire and slapstick, the chaplain left us with the most provocative line of the night:
True worship starts when we leave the church.
Other lines came close, and others in the audience may pick some that I missed. In Step Outside, which tells the story of a 34-mile march and sit-in to protest Wells Fargo’s investment in fossil fuels in 2019, no-one is deluded to think that the act itself will stop anything. But they know it can trigger something, like the proverbial snowball into avalanche. As one woman puts it:
It feels better to take the first step–even if you don’t know what the next step is.
Another woman notes the number of auto-body shops, car dealerships, gas stations, and parking lots they pass by. When it’s over, I tell people in the lobby that the April issue of Harper’s has an essay, “Lots to Lose,” on “parking psychosis” and the consequences of convenient parking spaces not just on the environment, but on the lives of communities large and small. One fellow recalled Joni Mitchell’s most catchy lyric, “They paved paradise and put up a parking lot.” Today, I check the magazine for the exact title and notice that it’s an excerpt from a book to be published next month: Paved Paradise.
Another film needed no dialogue at all. Choker shows a man awaiting a call that comes when a woman, bleeding from nose and mouth lands on a beach. Adults sun themselves and children play as she suffers, and the man races in his Jeep in an attempt at a rescue. Seems surreal until a change in the closing seconds that makes it all too real.
Transforming Lives and Landscapes serves as deep breaths of optimism by telling us of the Inga trees capable of restoring rich soil and crops in tropical climes where increasingly despoiled land is in need of it. Traces, the only feature (as opposed to documentary) of the evening, brings tears to the eye as it illustrates the freedom and joy of pre-industrial occupations.
All eleven films offer some hope, although the richly documented Butterflies & Borders about the rarely considered impact on wildlife and the environment made by walls built along the Rio Grande is a five-alarm from start to finish. As one environmentalist points out:
One mile of wall equals twenty acres paved out of production.
The woman in charge of the butterfly sanctuary is more blunt, comparing the disruption of migratory patterns to the privileges afforded the rich over the penalties charged to the poor. She also cited the nation’s disregard for science and “the dumbing down of America” as “self-sabotage” made possible in southern Texas and Arizona due to who lives there. The walls, the film later points out, only keeps them wandering in the desert longer, and the result is that more die–over 7,000 in five years, and that’s just a count of remains that were found.
My guess is that Butterflies won the audience favorite award because it was the most surprisingly informative, and perhaps the most urgent of an ever-urgent cast. As in the past, the audience receives a ballot with the printed program, and when it’s over, we vote for our favorite, and gather in the lobby where we are treated to snacks and treats supplied by Port City Sandwich. Judging from conversations while awaiting the result, I was far from alone having at least four films vying for my vote, though not often the same four, as each of the eleven took a fair share.
The screenings ended with the winner of the Festival’s third award, “Best Very Short Film,” Nature Now. In it, environmentalists Greta Thunberg and George Monbiot echo the call for first steps that we heard on the march to San Francisco, for a continued action even “when we leave the church,” and to vote for candidates who commit themselves to environmental sanity.
Intended or not, it served as a logical summary for the other ten films, while Thunberg’s presence re-echoed RFK’s call when I was barely her age to “rely on youth.” It was three young women not much older who posed a question that should be put to every candidate in every election for the foreseeable future. And the press must treat it as a yes-or-no question, interrupting anyone who begins with any other word, and insisting on an answer that begins with either yes or no:
Is our convenience worth the destruction?
-30-
Postscript: Some, if not all, of the films screened at the Festival will be available on the soon. I’ll add links when I have them, or you can check day to day at:
2023 official selections
As of now, the site has brief descriptions of all eleven films.





















